The Newbies, Part I

Scotland is in a veritable whisky boom. Never before in the history of Scotch whisky production (legal, at least…) has so many new distilleries been founded. Or so I’ve heard. To test such claims I scraped some data from the internet about opening and closing date of Scotch malt distilleries (mostly from wikipedia, whisky.com, lost distilleries) and I made the following graph:

And yes, it is clear that we’re seeing a historically high rate of new distilleries opening. The Lowlands and Islay are seeing a particular relative increase, and Campbeltown is going to explode in the coming years as well (I might do a per-region version of the graph later).

But the current rate is not quate as high as around the turn of the 20th century, when the number of malt distilleries also reached a peak that hasn’t been overtaken since, although in a few years time it may very well be. This boom from 120 years ago was also followed by 25 years of bust. The next, smaller boom in the ’60s was also nullified by the bust in the 80s. When will the current boom turn to bust, and what analysis will be drawn? In my understanding the current boom is much driven by the international trade, with up-and-coming large economies like China and India desiring premium liquor. Makes me think we’re going to see a lot of new distilleries closing when the global recession hits in a few years time. In any case, I’m little qualified for economic analysis, so I’ll leave it at that and get back to the whisky

Today I will sample a few of the new distilleries that are contributing to the current boom. Over the last few months I’ve started to collect samples with the idea to try all of them that I can get my hands on. Since before this I have already tried some without reviewing (Daftmill, Wolfburn, Abhainn Dearg, Nc’Nean, Glasgow, Kingsbarn, Ardnamurchan, Lindores Abbey), and a one I have reviewed, the amazing Dornoch. To this list we now add Hollyrood (Lowland), GlenWyvis (Highland), Roseisle (Speyside), and Torabhaig (Islands, Skye).

Let’s start with Holyrood. For 4 years I lived a minutes walk from this Newington, Edinburgh distillery. I used to jog past it every week. Somehow because of lockdown restrictions I never ended up at their distillery pub before I left. A friend and fellow WOLSer works there now, and another one used to do professional photography for them. In short, I feel some connection to this distillery without ever having entered it or tasted their whisky! (Gin I don’t give a rat’s ass about. I do have some Holyrood newmake that I tried but didn’t review yet). At last, we shall taste what whisky my neighbour’s have been making!

🌐

🪵


🔆

💲

🔗

Scotch single malt

Oloroso Butt, PX Hhd, Bourbon Brl, Rum Brq

undisclosed

on release ~€80, now unavailable; I paid €4.45 for 2cl from Brühler

whiskybase

Sample review

⚡Experience


A leading impression of cola and cinnamon on the nose, then cooked apples, buttered popcorn, and vegetable stock. Quite spicy palate, medium sweet, slightly bitter, with flavours of cereal, various nuts, grass, a little foam banana, and petrol; but it all lands a bit flat. Gingery finish.

💡Thoughts


Something in the flavour spectrum together with the bitterness rubs me the wrong way here. On the positive side, there is at least some character to be found, which I think is the most important thing for a new distillery. If a distillate-driven release from a new distillery was bland that would not bode well. Hopefully with improved age and the right kind of casks this will find its niche.


Unfulfilling
But there’s hope for the future!



🌐

🪵


🔆

💲

🔗

Scotch single malt

68% first fill ex-Bourbon, 15% refill whisky, 17% specialty wine casks. Batch 01/19

unchillfiltered & natural color

available for €55; I paid €6.85 for 5cl

whiskybase

Sample review

⚡Experience


Nose is exploding with candy (foam bananas, marshmallows), lemon pie, whipped cream, and fresh apricots. Somewhat one-dimensional and sugary, but endearing. Palate is sweet, with sponge cake, grass, subtle floral notes and cucumber. Just a hint of ashes in the development.

💡Thoughts


The young age is showing here, but it’s a clean and honest dram, in all its simplicity and new-makeiness. Nothing in the character strikes me as particularly unique or exciting though, so it remains to be seen how this will stand out in the crowd. But a clean distillate in the right cask can be all that’s needed for success.

Also props to GlenWyvis for an “integrity bottling” (high ABV, Non CF, no Color) and detailed info on the casks used!


Unfulfilling



Now, if this tasting is to be viewed as a competition, it’s not a fair fight. Against the other ~4yo younglings at ~46% comes a cask-strength Roseisle already matured to a good 12 years of age. The fact that this whisky is intended as a blend-filler I do not hold against it, as many of my favourite Speysiders are (Linkwood, being a prime example).

🌐

🪵


🔆

💲

🔗

Scotch single malt

first-fill ex-bourbon and refill casks

undisclosed

release price €120, still available; my sample €13.15 for 5cl (BWH)

whiskybase

Sample review

⚡Experience


Fresh tropical fruits (unripe mango, papaya, banana), floral notes (geranium), and fortified white wine. Touch of vanilla, cinnamon, and flour. The nose is quite closed at first but opens up with water, adding candied ginger and clotted cream. The palate is medium sweet, and the alcohol well integrated. Flavours are, surprisingly, more herbal and grassy than fruity; almost pungent, with a hint of tobacco leaf. Otherwise the impression is robustly malty.

💡Thoughts


We are dealing with a full-maturation whisky here. It’s not very complex, but it’s got a number of different things going for it that sustains my interest. I enjoy the contrast between the fresh and crisp and the slightly pungent. While I generally prefer bourbon casks, this is a spirit I think will carry a sherry casks really well.

Let’s speak about the price, though. At something like €120 it’s nowhere near to a recommended buy.


Worthwhile and Enjoyable



Finally, we arrive onto the Isle of Skye. Until Torabhaig opened in 2017, the famed Talisker was the lone whisky distillery on Isle of Skye.

🌐

🪵

🔆

💲


🔗

Scotch single malt

first fill bourbon barrels

unchillfiltered & natural color

readily available secondary market sub-€80; my sample €5.50 for 2cl from SoulOfWhisky

whiskybase

Sample review

⚡Experience


Nose: Sea spray, hickory smoke, crab sticks, lemon and green apples. Toast with honey and chevré on the palate; earthy peat, barely sugar, and lemon sherbet.

💡Thoughts


With peated whiskies, youth needs not be a hindrance and could even be an asset. This tasted like a fully capable and satisfying whisky already, albeit one of limited complexity.

Judging by the number of bottles available on the second hand market, even below €80, I think a lot people bought this because it’s an inaugural release and were hoping to flip it for a lot. Or maybe they didn’t have time to open it yet and by now there are more mature Ts out there that will be more worthwhile to drink?


Worthwhile and Enjoyable



That’s a wrap for this first foray into whisky newbies, or should we call them the ‘boomers’ already? It’s fun to try something really new. But rarely is young whisky, and especially form distilleries still finding their feet, so good that anything but curiosity can motivate the price of a full bottle, which is usually more expensive that well-aged whisky from established distilleries following the hype. The availability of small samples and whisky fair is therefore a real bliss, because the curiosity is definitely there!

Published by

6 responses to “The Newbies, Part I”

  1. […] continuing with the theme of trying out whisky from the New Wave of Scotch (malt) distilleries. There are currently 43 distilleries in this wave (with more in […]

    Like

  2. […] on to a new set of four distilleries in the new wave (The Newbies, Part I; The Newbies, […]

    Like

  3. […] have been trying a lot of newbie distilleries recently (Newbies Pt I, II, III) with the aim of getting through all of them eventually — a task that will take years […]

    Like

  4. […] perception clouded by thinking it must be Port Askaig? Probably some, but let’s compare with my review (not blind) of Torabhaig inaugural release: “Nose: Sea spray, hickory smoke, crab sticks, […]

    Like

  5. […] among enthusiast (and traders), as mature casks of the old stock came into circulation. In the present whisky boom, both distilleries, owned by Diageo, have reopened after extensive renovations, so technically they […]

    Like

  6. […] Roseisle 12, 56.5% […]

    Like

Leave a reply to Ghost safari #1 – DuckDrams Cancel reply