Buy or pass?

Today I’ll try samples that acquired of two recently released bottles that have been on my potential-buy list. Let’s see if I’ll be convinced to pull the trigger… or put the gun away.

Craigellachie • 15yo (2009) • 59.5% • Signatory Vintage

Scotch Single Malt • First-fill bourbon barrel • Natural Colour & Unchillfiltered • €90 • WB🔗

Tasting notes from a 5cl sample bottle

Nosing

Flowery, grassy, melon, bourbon vanilla, white pepper.

Deliciousness
Fun factor


Sipping

Starts off clean and refreshing: yellow apples, barley sugar, cream, vanilla, bonbons, with subtle smoke in the finish. The aftertaste is generic but very tasty bourbon oak, augmented with some caramelized lemon. A rather muscular spirit underneath it all.

Deliciousness
Fun factor


Comments

Nothing at all wrong with this one. Though, I’m mostly tasting a nice bourbon casks and the dirty distillery character is not very near at hand, except that smoky hint.

Laphroaig (Williamsson) • 14yo (2010) • 56.8% • Berry Bros. & Rudd

Scotch Single Malt • Barrel • Natural Colour & Unchillfiltered • €95 • WB🔗

Tasting notes from a 5cl sample bottle

Nosing

So there’s freshness and funkiness, and peat. My main impression is a yeasty Belgian blond or sour, and a smoked Aecht Shlenkerla rauchbier. Raspberries, yellow fruit, coconut, and hay, farm animal (shit), and blue cheese.

Deliciousness
Fun factor


Sipping

A certain sweetness and tartness. Heaps of ashy, peaty smoke. Malty and beery, yellow fruits (apricots etc), and ashiness.

Deliciousness
Fun factor


Comments

It’s excellent. I’m at the moment quite into the ‘farmy’ side of Laphroaig, and less the coastal and iodine, so this expression is great for me. For variation I’d happily take a bottle of this in between Port Charlotte 10s as the peat monster on my open bottle shelf. But I’m hesitating at the price which is almost the double!

In conclusion, both were great whiskies, but not so great that I’ll buy them at retail price. The Laphroaig I’d keep an eye out for on a sale or the auctions; for my Craigellachie fix I’ll look to other releases.

Published by

Leave a comment