The theme of today’s tasting is Some 2cl Samples of Old Vintage Speysiders That I Need to Drink Before They Go Bad. The first sample, a Tamdhu from Creative Whisky Company, I brought from the Limburg Whisky Festival 2025, and the other two, 1970s Cadenhead’s Benrinnes and Signatory Miltonduff, I got from Simple Sample as part of random sample packs, I think. I never heard about Creative Whisky Company before, their independent bottling operation seems to have between started in 2005 and ended 2018.
Tamdhu • 26yo (1984) • 48.4% • Creative Whisky Company
Scotch Single Malt • unavailable • WB🔗

Tasting notes from a 2cl sample bottle
Nosing
It’s an incredibly well-integrated nose of fruits, pastries, and that hard-to-describe (perhaps rancio’d) subtle leatheriness of an old-school whisky or cognac. Chocolate praline, marzipan, pistaccio, wiener bread, sultanas, orange zest, poached pear, leather, oak. It remains quite fresh an lively while also having this depth.
Deliciousness
Fun factor


Sipping
The alcohol is surprisingly aggressive for where it sits. Passion fruit curd, and puff pastry, along with a savouriness (prosciutto?), and smoke. Mentholic finish. Sadly, a bit of mini-sample cardboard taste, but I can look past it.
Deliciousness
Fun factor


Comments
To think this went on auction in 2019 for €150. I feel one rarely find this that are remotely affordable these days. Still, it’s far from a perfect dram. I find the palate to have a roughness or spirity quality that doesn’t live up to the gorgeous nose.
Benrinnes • 19yo (1971) • 50.2% • Cadenhead’s
Scotch Single Malt • unavailable • WB🔗

Tasting notes from a 2cl sample bottle
Nosing
At first rather closed. Juicy fruits and somewhat pungent flowers, buttery pastry, like shortbread, vanilla and cream, cinnamon.
Deliciousness
Fun factor


Sipping
Dense, savoury-sweet, robust and malty — very Benrinnes. It’s in the immediate finish the the “bigness” of the dram rolls out, juicy oak and mild tobacco and leather. More of the nuts and dried fruits in the aftertaste.
Deliciousness
Fun factor


Comments
A tasty dram, fo sho, but not at all better than similar-aged, less vintaged Benrinnes I’ve had. In the auction archives, I’ve found only one instance of a very similar bottle, likely a sister cask (CA, 1971/1991, 55.3%) and it went for €526 in 2020… Ridiculous waste of money.
Miltonduff • 19yo (1978) • 59% • Signatory Vintage
Scotch Single Malt • Sherry cask • unavailable • WB🔗

Tasting notes from a 2cl sample bottle
Nosing
A very dense and sherried nose, bringing to mind treacle, black liquorice, sulphur and broiled meats, shoe polish, damp wood and leather, green pepper sauce, almonds. And yet, there’s something bright and lively here too.
Deliciousness
Fun factor


Sipping
Throws a punch on the palate, but takes water well. Sweet, savoury, salty, with smoky undertones and liquorice, fruit leather, brown sugar, plum juice, raisins providing a non-too subtle but oh-so delicious show. Distillery character? None.
Deliciousness
Fun factor


Comments
Reminds me a lot of a 5yo-ish Adelphi Ben Nevis I had a bottle of an absolutely adored. Borderline ❤️ here, but we’re not quite there. €365 at auction back in 2020, not seen since.


Leave a comment