We continue after Part 1 with the second batch of 12 secret samples. One can surely expect a special finale!
Hercynian Whisky Co. | “The Alrik Limited Exclusive” | 55.1% | Official
from a 2cl sample bottle tasted blindly
๐๏ธ Tasting notes
Nosing
Toffee, sticky pudding, marmalade, wood, herbal tea. Finally, in the empty glass I’m getting many farmy, and yeasty dark ale notes.
Sipping
Sweet, big and round. Pecan pie, shortbread, fig chutney.
๐ญ Comments
Before reveal
Maybe tonight I’m having a sugar craving, ’cause this is really going down a treat! Usually, though, these “sweet & sticky” drams become too overbearing for my taste. There is something beyond the generic about this dram, although I can’t put my finger on it.
Heavy cask influence, I’ll guess PX (and I too often do, but this time with true conviction… unless it’s another sweet wine). Around 8yo, 55%, origin unknown. Wouldn’t be too surprise to discover this was Indian or other non-Scotch. In any case, this is surely malt.
After reveal
Non-Scotch malt? Check! PX casks? Check! 55%? Check! Age not stated but my guess has to be close given it’s a young distillery. *Pats self on back* Apparently the malt has been smoked with beech and alder wood. That might be the exotic factor I was looking for. Good whisky, but really expensive for a 50cl bottle, though.
Deliciousness
Fun factor
Value for money
Punchline
โซ๐ก๐ข
โซ๐กโซ
๐ด๐กโซ
A “sticky” delight
Arran | 27yo | 47.8% | That Boutique-y Whisky Co.

๐
Scotch single malt
๐ชต
puncheon
๐
unchillfiltered & natural color
๐ฒ
โฌ225 (50cl)
๐
from a 2cl sample bottle tasted blindly
๐๏ธ Tasting notes
Nosing
Delicately fragrant and evocative, very mature and ‘fused’. To pick out some specifics, there’s mandarins, apples, elderflower, tulips, peach, and light dusting of vanilla and cinnamon.
Sipping
Oily and juicy, but also quite ephemeral. Citrus candies and dried mulberries in the finish.
๐ญ Comments
Before reveal
One of those special drams that takes the express route from the olfactory bulb into the hippocampus, triggering diffuse emotional memories of summertime awe and wonder… Wish there was more!
Old to really-quite-old whisky, for sure – all the signs of a long, slow maturation are there. Shall we say 25-45yo? And single malt, although a blend would certainly not be out of the question (but surely it’s not all grain). Kinda Tullibardine-like… but could be any lighter-styled Low-/Highland/Speyside distillery in a very gentle bourbon or sherry cask. The ABV has sunk into the lower 40s.
After reveal
Oh la la! I had just seen this appear at WhiskyAgents. So fun I got to try it. Not guess wasn’t bad overall. A shame it’s so expensive and only a 50cl. Might keep an aye out for sale or auction, though.
Deliciousness
Fun factor
Value for money
Punchline
โซโซ๐ข
โซ๐ก๐ข
๐ก๐ดโซ
Hippocampal hit
โค๏ธ
“Speyside Finest” | 30yo (bott. 2024) | 52.5% | Brรผhler Whiskyhaus

๐
Scotch single malt
๐ชต
amontillado sherry hogshead
๐
unchillfiltered & natural color
๐ฒ
sold out; regular price was around โฌ250 I think
๐
from a 2cl sample bottle tasted blindly
๐๏ธ Tasting notes
Nosing
A slew of sour, fruity, sweet, woodsy and sharp aromas: buttery sherry, absinth, apple cider vinegar, damp wood โ and dill!
Sipping
Thick and sweet but there’s also a woody kind of sourness. Golden sultanas, toffee, toasted oats, herbs.
๐ญ Comments
Before reveal
I have no idea what this is, but is sure as haggis ain’t Scotch. Upper 50s ABV, probably youngish, and (at least partially) non-malty.
Also, “dill” came as a sudden epiphany towards the end of the dram, but now it’s so obviously there. I think it’s the first time ever I use this tasting note. That’s fun!
After reveal
Well, it was just a rather weird Scotch. I did notice when it appeared on BWH site. The 10cl was already โฌ40 and I didn’t want to take the chance even with that. Fun I got to try it anyways in the end.
Deliciousness
Fun factor
Value for money
Punchline
โซ๐กโซ
โซโซ๐ข
๐ก๐ดโซ
Dill!
Glengoyne | “The Three Maltketeers III” | 15yo (2008) | 56.1% | Official

๐
Scotch single malt
๐ชต
Spanish oloroso
๐
unchillfiltered & natural color
๐ฒ
โฌ140 (sold out)
๐
from a 2cl sample bottle tasted blindly
๐๏ธ Tasting notes
Nosing
Dark forest fruits, red wine, gummy bears, yellow mealy apple, tree sap, wood, hemp.
Sipping
On the sweet side, quite strong and a bit spicy. Sour cherries, milk chocolate, coffee, cinnamon.
๐ญ Comments
Before reveal
I’m sensing mostly the cask here (I’ll guess a red wine cask finish), but spriteliness shines through, leading me to think this is not so old, maybe 10yo less. Expecting to see 59%.
After reveal
The rating on whiskybase is insane: 89.87 with 54 votes. I’m just not getting it.
Deliciousness
Fun factor
Value for money
Punchline
โซ๐กโซ
โซ๐กโซ
๐ด๐กโซ
Sherried hype
Lagavulin | “Whispers of the Unexpected” | 16yo | 55.1% | Brave New Spirits

๐
Scotch single malt
๐ชต
bourbon barrel
๐
unchillfiltered & natural color
๐ฒ
โฌ145 (sold out)
๐
from a 2cl sample bottle tasted blindly
๐๏ธ Tasting notes
Nosing
Citrus (grapefruit, lemon), pine needles, mellow peat, seaweed and peach pebbles.
Sipping
Heavily peated, savoury, salty, dry. Lots of funk and farmyard aromas, some stone fruits.
๐ญ Comments
Before reveal
First, on the nose I had sensed peated Loch Lomond, but then on the palate it’s doubtless an Islay. Caol Ila. No, Stoaisha. NO. That farmy quality means it’s Laphroaig. Ex-bourbon cask. 57%. 7yo.
After reveal
And it’s still wrong. Lagavulin. I thought about it, but to me that usually has a more earthy flavour. This one was more citrus and hay. Oh, well.
Deliciousness
Fun factor
Value for money
Punchline
โซ๐กโซ
โซ๐กโซ
๐ด๐กโซ
Mildly unexpected, but not a whisper
“Irish Whiskey” | 25yo (1999) | 47.1% | Brรผhler Whiskyhaus

๐
Irish single malt
๐ชต
refill sherry hogshead
๐
unchillfiltered & natural color
๐ฒ
Sold out.
๐
from a 2cl sample bottle tasted blindly
๐๏ธ Tasting notes
Nosing
The predominant themes here are wood, flowers, and red berries. The wood is really quite intense, and enhanced by sour raspberries. Add cheesecake and geranium, and its quite a dense nose.
Sipping
Sweet and salty, really oily, and with some drying oak tannins. Lots of toffee, raspberry fudge, toasted pecans, and even some geranium petals. And, indeed, wood.
๐ญ Comments
It’s a richly flavourful and decadent dram, very obviously premium stuff. But something just doesn’t agree with me here, and it’s not just the excess of wood (although there certainly is that). Somewhere between sugary sweetness and the floral notes it get’s soapy.
I’ll guess this is a grain whisky close to 35-40yo from a sherry or perhaps even wine cask. 50ish%.
After reveal
Oops, it’s Irish single malt. Usually I really like that; here it didn’t work for me, but online people are liking it. I remember when this was sold on BWH, but I thought it was a bit pricey to take a chance. Glad I didn’t. I can’t find the price info, though. Probably โฌ200+
Deliciousness
Fun factor
Value for money
Punchline
๐ด๐กโซ
โซ๐ก๐ข
๐ด๐กโซ
Not everything is as it seems
Bowmore | “Masters’ Selection – Edition 3” | 22yo (bott. 2023) | 51.0% | Official

๐
Scotch single malt
๐ชต
European oak oloroso & American oak hogshead
๐
no info
๐ฒ
โฌ500
๐
from a 2cl sample bottle tasted blindly
๐๏ธ Tasting notes
Nosing
A complex nose, rich and mature. Leather, cigar box, and fragrant woody notes (juniper, rosemary), ginger (-ale), candied orange, blueberry jam, cola sauce.
Sipping
Incredibly flavourful. A real fruit bomb, lots of sweet citrus notes (grilled lemons), ripe strawberries, melon, and some fruity tobacco notes. Sweet and salty-savoury, with a texture that on the lighter side. Quite a noticeable of “cardboard defect”, unfortunately. Great, long finish, though.
๐ญ Comments
Before reveal
The general profile hints at an old and old-school malt. Together with cardboard defect, I suspect this could be a true vintage bottling of some highland malt, maybe Glenfarclas. So let’s say early 1980s. Not necessarily super-old, but 20+. Alcohol sub 50%. Really great nose, and flavours. Such a shame with the carboard defect, otherwise it would have been a โค๏ธ.
After reveal
Not a spectacular vintage, but a 22yo Bowmore is no shame, and indeed something one can have expectations from in terms of complexity and maturity. The cardboard likely has to do with the production/storage of the samples… Interestingly, there’s nary a peat particle in here! A tobacco smokiness, yes, but I didn’t entertain this to be a peated whisky.
But spare me the Aston Martin marketing, please.
Deliciousness
Fun factor
Value for money
Punchline
โซโซ๐ข
โซ๐ก๐ข
๐ดโซโซ
Aston-ishing
Mannochmore | 26yo (1996) | 49.8% | Gordon & MacPhail

๐
Scotch single malt
๐ชต
refill sherry hogshead
๐
unchillfiltered & natural color
๐ฒ
โฌ280
๐
from a 2cl sample bottle tasted blindly
๐๏ธ Tasting notes
Nosing
Perfectly ripe tropical fruits: mango purรฉe, pineapple, orange, coconut. Strong Trocadero vibe for me. Toasted oak and vanilla.
Sipping
Lightly sweet, with a tap of bitterness. A little bit of water does wonders to open up the flavours. Tropical fruit basket, subtle smoky note
๐ญ Comments
Before reveal
Amazing nose for a tropical fruit afficionado such as myself, 10/10. I was a little let down by the palate at first, but with some water my opinion of this dram made a full recovery! This could be a 25yo Glenlossie or some such (Or… Irish?). 50ish abv, obviously ex-bourbon. Based on the blind tasting, I would not hesitate to pay โฌ150. I’d say even at closer to โฌ200 it’s not a bad deal for me, given my preferences, although not a given.
After reveal
“Obviously ex-bourbon”, yet here we are with a refill sherry. WB people seem say nice old-school sherry. Really, I did not get the sherry vibes here. Sadly, the price is way closer to โฌ300 than โฌ200, and forget โฌ150 ๐ฅฒ
Deliciousness
Fun factor
Value for money
Punchline
โซโซ๐ข
โซ๐กโซ
๐ด๐กโซ
Tropical holiday
โค๏ธ
“Fiddichside” | 27yo (1997) | 45.3% | Murray McDavid

๐
Blended malt Scotch
๐ชต
bourbon hogshead + oloroso octave finish
๐
unchillfiltered & natural color
๐ฒ
โฌ200 (sold out)
๐
from a 2cl sample bottle tasted blindly
๐๏ธ Tasting notes
Nosing
Rife with bourbon cask tropical fruit, but with a green, grassy and herbal streak to it; add in some flowers and orange blossom too, shea butter, and wood.
Sipping
Dry and austere in basic taste. Then arrive the fruits, the vanilla, and toasty oak, further into tobacco and a subtle smoke or perhaps soot; combines with a fattiness in the texture for a pork-cracklings vibe. The finish turns more towards cocoa butter, vanilla (again), and some dried mulberries. Just a little hint of CD (Cardboard defect), perhaps OBE.
๐ญ Comments
Before reveal
Another one generally up my alley, but with a sooty/burned fat twist that I’m not sure to love or not, but it gets me really engaged. This one being drunk just after the previous one, I’m inclined to compare. Previous one is a more generous and straightforward tropical fruit hit, and over all more delicious. Oh, and what is it? I’m thinking some ex-bourbon Speysider/Highlander in the 20-30yo range, at a rather drinkable 46-48%.
After reveal
With an outturn of 86 bottles, and given the name, I guess we can safely assume this is essentially a Glenfiddich single malt. Indeed, that fatty aspect, without a real density or oiliness to the spirit, makes sense with a octave sherry finish actually.
Deliciousness
Fun factor
Value for money
Punchline
โซโซ๐ข
โซโซ๐ข
๐ด๐กโซ
Fatty finish
Ballechin (Edradour) | 19yo (2004) | 55% | Official

๐
Scotch single malt
๐ชต
first-fill manzanilla sherry butt
๐
natural color
๐ฒ
โฌ190
๐
from a 2cl sample bottle tasted blindly
๐๏ธ Tasting notes
Nosing
Pork belly barbecue and red wine. Kind of fatty, with lots of vegetal peat, and some herbs (thyme and rosemary). The wine carries red forest fruits, and then there’s some coastal spray and fresh-squeezed lemon. Hint of cheese / sweaty armpit with time.
Sipping
Very savoury, sweet, salty. An immediate rubber and iodine note, then smoked cold cuts, and oily sherry notes.
๐ญ Comments
Before reveal
From the nose I would say ex-red wine cask, but the palate has rather clear fatty sherry notes. It’s surely Islay, and most likely Laphroaig. ABV 53%.
After reveal
Aha, peated Edradour (Ballechin). It didn’t even cross my mind, but it makes total sense. Manzanilla sherry, sure.
Deliciousness
Fun factor
Value for money
Punchline
โซ๐ก๐ข
โซโซ๐ข
๐ด๐กโซ
Pork belly BBQ
Clynelish | “Symington’s Choice” | 26yo (1996) | 53.4% | Signatory Vintage

๐
Scotch single malt
๐ชต
oloroso sherry butt
๐
unchillfiltered & natural color
๐ฒ
โฌ750
๐
from a 2cl sample bottle tasted blindly
๐๏ธ Tasting notes
Nosing
We are in varnish, wood, leather, and tobacco territory, intersecting with dried plums and apricots, slightly sour grapes, caramelized sugar and cocoa. A touch of vegetable broth too. The oak wood is not overpowering, but quite present.
Sipping
Beautiful, silky texture; perfectly balanced sweetness and richness. Like a tart topped will all manner of ripe and tinned and liquor-soaked fruits: apricots, strawberries, oranges. There’s juicy oak in just the right amount. And a puff on a cigar, too. More nuts and dried fruits in the long finish.
๐ญ Comments
Before reveal
The nose is really interesting and complex, but not perfect. The palate, though, is just a straight 10/10. Perfect strength, texture… the noblest kind of oak juice. I would say, though, that this is the kind of super-mature juicy oak profile toward which, in my experience, many distilleries converge with age; we are largely savouring a (magnificent) cask. No particular quirks that would point to a certain single malt distillate, in my view, although peat malt is ruled out. I would quite confidently say ex-bourbon cask, or at most refill sherry. Strength is probably sub-50%, but hard to place. Age from 25yo upward, probably around 30yo. I’d probably be ready to spend โฌ300 on a bottle like this, but I suspect that won’t nearly cut it.
After reveal
Oh boy, Clynelish! It’s a favourite distillery; still, it’s not very obviously Clynelish-y, I’d say.
Deliciousness
Fun factor
Value for money
Punchline
โซโซ๐ข
โซโซ๐ข
๐ดโซโซ
The noblest oak juice
โค๏ธ
Glenfarclas* | “Images of Speyside” | 40yo (1982) | 54.9% | Sansibar

๐
Scotch single malt
๐ชต
sherry butt
๐
unchillfiltered & natural color
๐ฒ
โฌ800
๐
from a 2cl sample bottle tasted blindly
๐๏ธ Tasting notes
Nosing
Tropical fruits, gentle oak and leather; very “rancio”. Passion fruit , apricot, hint of wet forest, and a saline streak.
Sipping
Salt, sweetness, umami; brine. Tropical fruits galore, and a well-integrated peat. Just a hint of iodine. Apricot in the finish
๐ญ Comments
Before reveal
This is a 30yo Bowmore. Flawless, both nose and palate. But wait… We had an aged Bowmore before. So… Maybe its 25yo Springbank? I’m lost.
After reveal
And now I’m also stumped. I was so sure I was getting peat, and it’s a Speysider. According to one retailer it is Glenfarclas. I guess I’m getting smokiness and lots of wood spice, and once the idea of it being a peated dram that softened out over the year takes hold, it plays tricks on the mind (I would not expect salt or iodine from a GF). In any case, this was a treat.
Deliciousness
Fun factor
Value for money
Punchline
โซโซ๐ข
โซโซ๐ข
๐ดโซโซ
Flawless
โค๏ธ
And with that, Christmas is finally over and done, with a great finale. Five โค๏ธ were contained in these 24 samples, and quality drams all the way through.
Pre-booking for the 2026 calendar should start in about a month, and I will be ready!



Leave a comment