The year is heading towards its end, and so are quite a few bottles that have long occupied the top shelf of my drinks cabinet where all the open bottles live a crowded life. It is indeed a good time to make room for the new immigrants that will be cracked open in 2025, so in the past month or two I’ve finishing off bottles and collecting my final reviews in this post. This is also my chance to record (for my on reminiscence) where, how, why I got these bottles, in addition to my final impression on the taste.
Clynelish | “Cl-Br: 177-9n” | 2005/2020 | 46% | Official

๐
Scotch single malt
๐ชต
double matured in oloroso seco cask
๐
unchillfiltered
๐ฒ
โฌ125 in recent auctions; I paid ยฃ58.50 at Lagavulin distillery
๐
own bottle kill
๐๏ธ Tasting notes
Nosing
The main themes are a gentle sherry, coastal minerality, fresh fruits (especially citrus), and some dusty oak and a whiff of a struck matchstick. Digging into the fruitier side, there’s lemon, orange, and apples. The sherry brings a nuttiness, dried fruits, along with caramel. There is a bit of waxiness, if I search for it.
Sipping
A nice balance of sweetness and brine, very round and velvety in texture. The flavours concur with the nose: sherry, citrus, mineral. A subtle tobacco-y smoke in the finish. Very drinkable.
๐ญ Comments
It’s really enjoyable and quaffable dram. The sherry, while prominent, is not dominating the experience, with room for the citrus and especially the dusty and smoky tinge to make things more exciting. I bought two bottles of this at Lagavulin distillery for ยฃ58.50 a piece during the 2023 Islay trip. I’m quite happy I did. This has been a bottle I often turned to when I just wanted to enjoy a dram, perhaps with a chocolate on the side, while reading, playing games, or watching something. It’s just delicious, not too simple or complex.
Deliciousness
Fun factor
Value for money
Punchline
โซโซ๐ข
โซ๐กโซ
โซ๐ก๐ข
Uncomplicated goodness
“Sutherland” | 5yo (bott. 2023) | 48.5% | Thompson Bros.

๐
Scotch blended malt
๐ชต
refill bourbon and sherry butt
๐
unchillfiltered & natural color
๐ฒ
I paid โฌ107.50
๐
own bottle kill
๐๏ธ Tasting notes
Nosing
White- and yellow fleshed fruit (litchi, crisp apples), wax candle, pineapple and ham, a hint of vegetable stock and green pepper.
Sipping
Beautifully oily and silky, goes down a treat neat. Meaty mango chutney, dirty-peaty, coastal, fresh. Inca berries, juicy oak, and a tad of bitterness in the finish.
๐ญ Comments
This is the bottle I’ve enjoyed the most in the past year, though I think I opened it around October 2023. It’s a blend of mostly Clynelish (100L 9yo + 214L 8yo, both from refill bourbon) and bit of Dornoch distillery (64L 5yo, Bodega sherry butt – refill Glen Moray barrel), and teaspooned with Brora (1982/2015 Gordon & MacPhail). It just really satisfies me in my current phase of craving an dirty tropical fruit style without much peat influence.
Deliciousness
Fun factor
Value for money
Punchline
โซโซ๐ข
โซ๐ก๐ข
โซ๐ก๐ข
My bottle of the year 2024
โค๏ธ
Personal favourite
“Grande Champagne Brandy” | 28yo (1993) | 54.0% | Spheric Spirits

๐
Brandy from Cognac
๐ชต
2nd fill sherry hogshead
๐
unchillfiltered & natural color
๐ฒ
I paid โฌ136.90 in Dec 2022; still available at comparable price
own bottle kill
๐๏ธ Tasting notes
Nosing
Red grape skins, leather, old chest, a little tiger balm.
Sipping:
Sweet, but not sticky; rich with lots of umami; some oak, but not too many tannins. Red, dried fruits, walnuts, hint of menthol.
๐ญ Comments
Oxidation has certainly done wonders here! This is unusual, in that it’s cognac that was matured in Scotland in an ex-sherry cask. As I recall, I bought this online based on a hunch that it would be worth the money, and I’d say it was.
Deliciousness
Fun factor
Value for money
Punchline
โซโซ๐ข
โซ๐กโซ
โซ๐ก๐ข
Quality old cognac
Glen Garioch | 12yo | 48% | Official

๐
Scotch single malt
๐ชต
bourbon & sherry
๐
unchillfiltered, caramel colour adjusted
๐ฒ
Can usually be found around โฌ40
๐
own bottle kill
๐๏ธ Tasting notes
Nosing: baked pears with vanilla, earthy heather, orange peel, banana, forest honey, dark bread
Palate: rich, sweet and malty, pears, sultanas, gingerbread, spicy
๐ญ Comments
This really is a bottle overkill. I brought two-thirds full bottle to a small wedding reception and it got emptied except for a few drops that I now try to write a very compromised review from.
This is actually the whisky I have bought the most bottles of (4). I first got it for a colleague tasting (but ended up not including it), and have now and again picked up bottles when I’ve seen it for close to โฌ35. This is the second bottle I finish.
I think it just a really lovely Highland malt, with things I like from both the bourbon and sherry side of things, and this heathery, earthy aroma that spurs my memory of the great outdoors, and get a bit nostalgic about living in Scotland.
I recall the charismatic Ralfy (online reviewer) not being too impressed with it; that the high alcohol is there to bring life to the tired casks being used. Might very well be true. It even has caramel colouring, although no chill-filtration it seems. Still, I can’t help to enjoy this stuff, and there’s not much competition at โฌ35!
Deliciousness
Fun factor
Value for money
Punchline
โซ๐ก๐ข
โซ๐กโซ
โซโซ๐ข
A Highland benchmark
Kilchoman | “Sanaig” | 46% | Official

๐
Scotch single malt
๐ชต
70% oloroso sherry, 30% bourbon
๐
unchillfiltered & natural color
๐ฒ
โฌ45
๐
own bottle kill
๐๏ธ Tasting notes
Nosing
Fresh coastal character, sweet peat, and a balanced sherry profile: nuts, coffee, cola, sultana, strawberry, pear, vanilla, hay / dry grass, heather, smoked sausage, grilled corn, leather, fresh seaweed.
Sipping
Only medium sweet, slightly salty and savoury. Rich and warming peat, treacle, tropical fruit (appears also on the nose after a while), and seafood barbeque.
๐ญ Comments
Banger of peated whisky. It may be worth noting that the final 5cl of the bottle have been sitting there for a long time (year?), but it remains great. In fact, I like it more now than I remember doing before even.
I bought this bottle to use at a tasting for my colleagues, and as I recall it was quite well appreciated. I later brought samples for hikes, and other adventures with Swedish friends, four of which ended up buying their own bottle after that.
Deliciousness
Fun factor
Value for money
Punchline
โซโซ๐ข
โซ๐ก๐ข
โซโซ๐ข
A new Islay classic


Leave a comment